• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pudgie's Pizza & Subs: Delightful Pizza, Wings, and Subs in Ithaca, NY

Pudgie's Pizza & Subs, located at 215 Elmira Rd in Ithaca, NY, is a beloved local eatery known for its delicious pizza, crispy wings, and hearty subs. Customers rave about the friendly, efficient service that makes ordering a breeze, even for delivery to loved ones in need. The emphasis on quality ingredients shines through, with pizzas cooked to cheesy perfection and fresh-cut salads that complement any meal. The inviting atmosphere welcomes diners, ensuring a pleasurable experience from start to finish. Whether you’re indulging in signature pizzas or savoring flavorful wings, Pudgie's guarantees satisfaction with every bite.

Photos & Gallery

Pudgie's Pizza & Subs: Reviews & Ratings

Cindy Mullaney
Cindy Mullaney

Always si easy to send wings or pizza to my brother who is in Ithaca in a rehabilitation center from a stroke. They are always polite and deliver his food on time and promptly. I just call from my home and I know he will receive it. Great company to deal with!

Jordan Terrell
Jordan Terrell

The staff was extremely quick and efficient and they were very hospitable. I ordered three sheets extra cooked, only one was and the wings were supposed to be crispy, but they weren’t. I ordered 100 wings, so I’m guessing they probably overcrowded the fryer to get everything done according to my schedule. But everyone was pretty much satisfied.

Kristy Brame
Kristy Brame

Great pizza=Great people - Thank You for the delicious pizza, wings, subs, and fresh cut salads.

Shane Allen
Shane Allen

I walked in and was immediately welcomed, I didn’t feel pressured or rushed, food was delicious, the pizza was so cheesy and cooked to perfection, the pizza frette, was amazing, definitely going back soon with friends

Location

Welcome to the vibrant world of Pudgie's Pizza & Subs, a beloved establishment nestled in the heart of Ithaca, NY. Located at 215 Elmira Rd, this charming eatery specializes in serving delicious pizzas, mouthwatering wings, hearty subs, and fresh-cut salads. With a phone number as easy to remember as their delectable offerings, you can reach them at +1 607-272-7600.

At Pudgie's, the ambiance is warm and inviting. The friendly staff quickly makes you feel at home, promising a dining experience marked by hospitality and efficiency. Customer reviews reflect the restaurant’s commitment to excellence. For instance, many patrons, like Cindy Mullaney, appreciate the reliable delivery service that brings joy and satisfaction to loved ones unable to dine out. Cindy's brother, currently in a rehabilitation center, enjoys timely pizza and wings, showcasing the compassionate nature of Pudgie's team.

However, no restaurant is without its minor hiccups. Jordan Terrell noted that while he ordered a large quantity of wings to be cooked crispy, the end results were a bit uneven. Still, with 100 wings at stake, it’s understandable that timing constraints might lead to some overcrowding in the fryer. Fortunately, even with this slight mishap, guests left with smiles, indicating that the flavors of Pudgie’s other dishes, including the pizza, made a lasting impression.

Customers rave about the great pizza, and Kristy Brame sums it up perfectly: “Great pizza = Great people.” She emphasizes the delicious menu offerings that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. Whether it’s a classic cheese pie or richly topped specialty pizza, every bite is an expression of quality and care in food preparation.

For those looking for something a bit more unique, don’t miss out on the pizza fritte, a crispy delight that has made waves in taste and texture, leaving guests like Shane Allen eager for a return visit. The blend of cheesy goodness and perfectly cooked crust showcases the culinary artistry that Pudgie’s embodies.

In summary, Pudgie's Pizza & Subs is not just about satisfying hunger; it’s about building community through food and fostering connections among friends and family. So next time you're in Ithaca, treat yourself to a meal that offers more than just flavor—it provides an experience to cherish with every bite.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Drive-through
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards