Pudgie's Pizza & Subs Menu

  1. Overview
  2. Menu
Pudgie's Pizza & Subs 1
Pudgie's Pizza & Subs 2

Welcome to Pudgie's Pizza & Subs, located in the heart of Ithaca, NY. This local gem is a haven for pizza lovers, offering freshly made pizzas, sub sandwiches, and crispy wings. Here, the focus is not just on the food, but also on the warm and welcoming service provided by the staff.

Customers rave about the delicious, cheesy pizzas, perfectly cooked to satisfy any craving. The wings, though occasionally a hit-or-miss in crispiness, are undeniably popular, especially for gatherings. Reviews highlight the efficient, friendly service that makes ordering a breeze, whether it's for a group event or a comforting meal for a loved one.

Pudgie's embraces quality and community, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors alike. With an extensive menu that includes fresh-cut salads and subs, there's something to please every palate.

Sauces
Packages
Subs
Fryers
Pizza
Crowd Pleasers
Drinks
Stromboli
Slices
Cookies
Pasta
Salad

Sauces

BBQ Side
US$0.73

Mild Side
US$0.73

Garlic Butter
US$0.73

Marinara Side
US$0.73

French Dressing
US$0.73

Hot Side
US$0.73

XHot Side
US$0.73

Honey BBQ Side
US$0.73

Pizza Sauce Side
US$0.73

Medium Side
US$0.73

Blue Cheese

2 oz Cup
US$0.73

Tin Of Marinara
US$4.04

Honey Mustard
US$0.73

Ranch

2 oz Cup
US$0.73

Italian
US$0.73

Golden
US$0.73

Family Pleaser

1 Large Pizza with 2 Large Breadsticks, 2 Pastas and 2 Garden Salads
US$46.66

Triple Treat

3 Medium
US$38.39

Party Pack

Sheet Pizza, 20 Wings and 2 Large Drinks
US$66.09

Packages

Subs

Itailian

Salami, capicola, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
US$0.00

Pudgie Burger

Pudgie burger, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe and onion
US$0.00

Buffalo Chicken Sub

Chicken, medium sauce, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomato and onion
US$0.00

Hot Ham & Cheese

Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion and mayo
US$0.00

Ham & Cheese

Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
US$0.00

Chicken Club

Chicken, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe and onion
US$0.00

Chicken Parm

Chicken, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese
US$0.00

Super

Salami, capicola, ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
US$0.00

Meatball Sub

Meatball, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese
US$0.00

Cheesesteak

Cheesesteak, cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe and onion
US$0.00

Turkey

Turkey, lettuce, tomatoe, onion, mayo and sub oil
US$0.00

French Fries
US$3.36

Pizza Frette

Fried dough with confectionary sugar
US$4.53

20 Wings

20 chicken wings
US$37.75

10 Wings

10 chicken wings
US$19.96

Chicken Tenders
US$10.76

Mozzrella Sticks
US$8.43

Fryers

Pizza

Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Meat Sauce and Bacon
US$29.98

Cheesy Breadstick Sheet
US$33.46

Breadstick Sheet
US$26.98

Deep Dish

Square pizza cut into 16 slices
US$23.60

Chicken Bacon Ranch
US$24.61

Everything Pizza

Pepperoni, Sausage, Meat Sauce, Onion, Green Pepper and Mushrooms
US$29.98

Veggie Pizza

Tomatoes, Onions, Green Peppers, Broccoli and Mushrooms
US$29.98

Large Pizza

17" round pizza cut into 12 slices
US$23.60

Medium Pizza

13" round pizza cut into 6 slices
US$16.56

Sheet Pizza

Rectagular pizza cut into 32 slices
US$33.07

Chicken Wing Pizza
US$0.00

Sub Platter

15 4" Subs with Lettuce, Onion and Tomatoe condiments on the side
US$62.21

Large Salad

Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Choice of Dressing (Feeds 20-25)
US$46.52

Medium Salad

Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Choice of Dressing (Feeds 8-10)
US$32.03

Large Pasta

***NEEDS 24 HOURS OF NOTICE** Serves 20-25
US$52.61

Crowd Pleasers

Drinks

Can
US$2.68

Gatorade

Fruit Punch
US$3.88

Bottle Of Water
US$2.68

Large Drink

32 oz Drink
US$3.75

Small Drink

16 oz Drink
US$2.68

Small Stromboli

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, green peppers, pizza sauce, american cheese and mozzarellla cheese
US$19.44

Custom Stromboli

Make your own
US$19.44

Large Stromboli

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, green peppers, pizza sauce, american cheese and mozzarellla cheese
US$30.74

Stromboli

Slices

Pizza Roll
US$6.48

Stromboli Slice

Pepperoni, ham, sausage, green peppers, pizza sauce, american cheese and mozzarella cheese
US$7.57

Stromboli Special
US$9.58

Plain Special
US$8.43

Plain Slice
US$3.88

Pepperoni Slice
US$4.01

Pepperoni Special

2 pepperoni slices and a drink of your choice
US$8.68

Slice & Breadstick Special
US$8.03

Pizza Roll Special
US$7.12

Bread Sticks
US$5.11

3 Chocolate Chip Cookies
US$5.19

1 Chocolate Chip Cookie
US$1.95

10 Chocolate Chip Cookies
US$15.57

24 Chocolate Chip Cookies
US$31.14

Cookies

Pasta

Pasta Dinner

Pasta, small bread sticks and a side salad
US$13.48

Rigatoni
US$10.76

Spaghetti
US$10.76

Chicken Salad

Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, chicken and dressing of choice
US$9.69

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, chicken sauced in medium sauce and dressing of choice
US$9.69

Garden Salad

Lettuce, onions, tomatoes and dressing of choice
US$7.64

Side Salad

Lettuce, onions, tomatoes and dressing of choice
US$5.38

Chef Salad

Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, turkey, ham, cheese and dressing of choice
US$9.69

Salad